This was done in order to replicate milgram as closely as possible, which as part of their aims, but this means that the sample may well not be representative of the dutch people. Destructive obedience without pressure archive ouverte hal. They also thought that giving shocks was an old fashioned way of punishing people. It involves understanding what powerful dynamic factors come into play during the human character metamorphosis within different circumstances.
Sep 12, 2016 meeus and raaijmakers psychology study of obedience. The scared is a 41item child and parent selfreport instrument assessing dsmiv symptoms of panic disorder, sad, gad, sp, and school phobia. Its goal is to account for data observed in a variety of memory experiments using a variety of retrieval measures free recall, cued recall, and recognition. Compared to meeus and raaijmakers setting, however, in which negative remarks. Leary m r wheeler d s jenkins t b 1986 aspects of identity. Petrie, 1986 and a musical preference is a valued and important dimension of adolescents social identity tarrant et al. Build free mind maps, flashcards, quizzes and notes create, discover and share resources.
Milgrams variations and meeus and raaijmakers prezi. Our paradigm was modeled after that of the utrecht studies on obedience meeus and raaijmakers european journal of social psychology 16. Subjects had to obey an alleged head of personnels order to disturb an applicant during a job interview. The lucifer effect presents how good people turn evil. The social psychology of psychological research, the free press.
Obedience, power, and leadership principles of social. To investigate destructive violence in the everyday situation of a job interview. In their fascinating study, meeus and raaijmakers, 1986, meeus and raaijmakers, 1987 transposed the milgram paradigm to an organizational setting in which the suffering inflicted by the experimental subjects was not physical but psychological. Sep 14, 2015 evaluation the generalisability of meeus and raaijmakers 1986 study is questionable as they used a self selectedvolunteer sample. They thought parts of it were ambiguous for example, the participants were told the shocks were not dangerous and yet the shock generator said. It was a way of replicating milgrams study in a more ecologically valid setting. Meeus and raaijmakers study of obedience from another culture. Responding to material and ideational misalignments aafke raaijmakers, patrick a. Study of obedience meeus and raaijmakers by prezi user. Unwersity of utrecht, heidelbergaan 2, 3584 cs utrecht, the netherlands a bstract. This research explores the psychological factors potentially involved in fostering disobedience to an unjust authority. Social psychology meeus and raaijmakers key study on. Meeus and raaijmakers obedience human behavior social. Meeus and raaijmakers study of obedience from another culture aim.
They wanted to use a method that was not ambiguous as whether behaviour was harmful some questioned this in milgrams study and believed that pps were unsure about how. To see if obedience could be replicated using a modern method that was more realistic to everyday life. A gapped presentation for students to introduce the key study by meeus and raaijmakers in 1986 on the crosscultural differences in obedience. Replications of milgrams study meeus and raaijmakers 1986 conducted a from psyc 2310 at university of guelph. Obedience research the specification requires you to know one of milgrams variations. Meeus and raaijmakers obedience human behavior experiment. Heterogeneity in development of adolescent anxiety disorder symptoms in an 8year longitudinal community study volume 26 issue 1 stefanie a. This break, absent in both milgram 1963 and meeus and raaijmakers 1986 paradigms, was actually introduced to increase the intensity of. It compares milgrams original study with one carried out in the netherlands. Meeus and raaijmakers psychology study of obedience teaching. Aim to see whether more modern psychologicaladministrative violence creates more less obedience as compared to milgrams method to see whether milgrams findings can be replicated twenty years later in a more liberal dutch culture to see if harm would be done if participants clearly understood they would be causing damage to investigate a. Leary m r wheeler d s jenkins t b 1986 aspects of identity and behavioral from hu 204deo at tristate bible college.
Meeus and raaijmakers psychology study of obedience. The scared has excellent psychometric properties in clinical birmaher et al. Meeus and raaijmakers 1986 meeus and raaijmakers addressed some issues with milgrams study by conducting a similar study with key changes some issues with milgrams study how meeus and raaijmakers addressed these issues is physical harm normal. D is professor at the university of amsterdam department of forensic child and youth care sciences. If your address has been previously registered, you will receive an email with instructions on how to reset your password. This article is within the scope of wikiproject philosophy, a collaborative effort to improve the coverage of content related to philosophy on wikipedia. The role of music preferences in early adolescents. Evidence for two interactive learning components joseph m. Destructive obedience without pressure social psychology. Carrying out orders to use psychologicaladministrative violence wim h. Educational and psychological measurement, 59, 725748.
This break, absent in both milgram 1963 and meeus and raaijmakers 1986. To see if obedience could be replicated using a modern method that was more realistic. Pdf destructive obedience without pressure researchgate. They thought parts of it were ambiguous like for example, the participants were told the shocks were not dangerous and yet the shock generator said. However, he only ordered participants to go up to 150v.
Burger 2009 produced similar results to milgram 70%. Pdf studies on obedience to authority highlight the power of the situation. If you continue browsing the site, you agree to the use of cookies on this website. Effectiveness of different missing data treatments in surveys with likerttype data.
Experimente unter dem milgramparadigma springerlink. If you would like to support the project, please visit the project page, where you can get more details on how you can help, and where you can join the general discussion about philosophy content on wikipedia. In the present experiment, we tested a more widespread form of authority. Specifically, to see to what extent people will obey orders to psychologically abuse a job interviewee. Meeus and raaijmakers 1986 by chris branson on prezi. Carrying out orders to use psychologicaladministrative violence. Replications of milgrams study meeus and raaijmakers. It includes the aim, procedure, results and conclusion of the study and an evaluation at the end. Took place in a modern university in holland a country known for its more liberated culture. Introducing the relative mean substitution approach. Meeus and raaijmakers were critical of milgrams research. To be able to describe and evaluate one variation of milgrams study and one study on obedience from a different country to milgram. Meeus and raaijmakers 1986 step 1 39 dutch people of both genders aged 1855 were paid to take part in this experiment asked to administer psychological harm in the form of 15 increasingly insulting remarks to a stranger confederate.